How to Choose the Best Fire Pit for Your Backyard

A fire pit is more than just an outdoor feature; it's the heart of your backyard, where friends and family gather for warmth, conversation, and relaxation. Whether you're looking for a cozy fire for small get-togethers or a dramatic centerpiece for entertaining guests, choosing the right fire pit requires careful consideration.

Read Our Story — Get to know our team, what drives us, and why we’re qualified to sell gas fire pits after 35 years in the industry. 

In this guide, you will learn:

• What Are the Different Types of Fire Pits
• How to Choose the Right Material for Your Fire Pit
• Best Size and Placement for Your Fire Pit
• Fuel Options: Propane vs. Natural Gas vs. Wood
• Popular Features and Accessories to Enhance Your Fire Pit
• How Much Money Can You Expect To Spend On Various Fire Pits 

1. What Are the Different Types of Fire Pits?

Before making a purchase, it's essential to understand the different types of fire pits available and how they align with your needs and aesthetic preferences.

Gas Fire Pits

For those who prioritize convenience, gas fire pits offer instant ambiance with the flip of a switch. These modern options eliminate the need for firewood preparation and cleanup, providing a sophisticated fire feature that can be enjoyed with minimal effort throughout the year.

Pros

• Easy ignition and instant flame
• Low maintenance, no ash cleanup
• Clean-burning with no smoke
• Customizable media (glass beads, lava rocks, ceramic logs)

Cons

• Requires gas line installation or propane refills
• Higher upfront cost
• Lacks the traditional crackle and wood smell

Best for: Homeowners who want convenience and a modern look.

Wood-Burning Fire Pits

Nothing beats the classic experience of a wood-burning fire pit, bringing warmth and nostalgia to any gathering. These traditional fire features engage all the senses with their crackling sounds, dancing flames, and distinctive aroma that evokes memories of campfires and cozy evenings under the stars.

Pros

• Traditional campfire feel and crackling sound
• High heat output
• Ideal for cooking (marshmallows, grilling)

Cons

• Requires wood storage and cleanup
• Produces smoke
• May be restricted in some areas

Best for: Those who love the authentic ambiance of real flames and the unmistakable smell of burning wood, who enjoy the ritual of building and tending to a fire, and who appreciate the superior heat output for cool evenings or cooking applications like roasting marshmallows or grilling food.

Smokeless Fire Pits

A smokeless fire pit is the perfect solution if you love real fire but hate the smoke. These innovative designs utilize advanced airflow systems and secondary combustion technology to dramatically reduce smoke output while still providing the authentic wood-burning experience that many outdoor enthusiasts crave.

Pros

• Minimal smoke with better airflow design
• Efficient burning with fewer emissions
• Real wood-burning feel without the smoke

Cons

• More expensive than basic wood pits
• Still requires ash cleanup
• Smoke-free startup not guaranteed

Best for: People who want the charm of wood-burning fires without excessive smoke, those with close neighbors or smoke-sensitive family members, and environmentally conscious homeowners who want to minimize their ecological footprint while still enjoying real wood fires.

Fire and Water Features

These stunning fire pits combine fire and water elements for an ultra-luxurious backyard centerpiece. By merging the hypnotic qualities of dancing flames with the serene movement of flowing water, these installations create a multisensory experience that transforms any outdoor space into a resort-like retreat.

Pros:

• Striking luxury design
• Multisensory: fire + flowing water
• Increases property value

Cons: 

• High cost and professional install required
• Requires water and gas hookups
• Higher maintenance

Best for: Homeowners who want to create a high-end outdoor experience reminiscent of luxury resorts, those who frequently entertain and desire a conversation-starting focal point, and property owners looking to make a significant investment in outdoor living space that provides year-round visual interest even when not in use.

DIY Fire Pits

For hands-on homeowners, DIY fire pits allow for complete customization while decreasing costs.

Pros:

• Budget-friendly
• Fully customizable
• Great for DIY enthusiasts

Cons:

• Requires tools, labor, and safety knowledge

Best for: Creative homeowners who enjoy building things themselves.

2. How to Choose the Right Material for Your Fire Pit

Fire pits come in a variety of materials, each offering unique aesthetic and functional benefits. Whether you prioritize durability, portability, or a specific style, selecting the right material is essential to ensuring your fire pit meets both your needs and outdoor design preferences.

Stone and Concrete Fire Pits

These are among the most durable and weather-resistant options available. Built to withstand harsh outdoor conditions, concrete fire pits offer a natural, timeless look that blends seamlessly into any backyard setting. Due to their weight, they are best suited for permanent installations, making them an excellent choice for homeowners looking to create a long-lasting outdoor fire feature.

Steel Fire Pits

Steel Fire Pits provide a modern, sleek appearance and are often favored for their lightweight construction and versatility. If powder-coated, steel fire pits become rust-resistant, increasing their lifespan and durability. Their portability makes them ideal for homeowners who want a stylish fire pit that can be easily moved or repositioned within their outdoor space. Additionally, steel fire pits are available in various contemporary designs, adding a sophisticated touch to any backyard.

Copper Fire Pits

Copper Fire Pits exude luxury and elegance, making them a premium option for those who want their fire pit to double as a statement piece. Over time, copper develops a beautiful patina that enhances its visual appeal, giving it a rustic yet refined look. However, this material is more expensive than stone or steel and requires occasional polishing to maintain its original luster. Despite the maintenance, copper fire pits remain a top choice for homeowners who value aesthetics and uniqueness.

3. Best Size and Placement for Your Fire Pit

When selecting a fire pit, size and placement are key factors that impact safety and enjoyment. Whether designing an intimate patio retreat or an entertainer’s dream backyard, finding the right fit will ensure your fire pit enhances the space while remaining functional and compliant with safety guidelines.

How to Choose the Right Size

• Small (under 30 inches):
  Perfect for compact patios, balconies, or small yards, a small fire pit creates an intimate atmosphere and provides enough warmth for 2-4 people. It is ideal for urban settings or homes with limited outdoor space.

• Medium (30-40 inches):
  This size is the most versatile and suits most backyards. It accommodates 4-6 people gatherings and balances cozy ambiance and functionality, making it an excellent choice for family or casual social events.

• Large (over 40 inches):
  Designed for larger patios and expansive outdoor spaces, a fire pit of this size is best for entertaining bigger groups of 6-10 people. It creates a stunning focal point and ample warmth for extended outdoor gatherings.

Placement Tips

Proper placement is crucial for safety, comfort, and maximizing your fire pit's usability. Keep these factors in mind:

• Maintain a Safe Distance: Always position the fire pit 10 feet away from structures, fences, and flammable materials like overhanging branches or dry vegetation. If using a gas fire pit, follow manufacturer recommendations for clearance.
• Consider Wind Direction: Place your fire pit where prevailing winds won’t blow smoke toward seating areas or directly into your home. Adding a windguard can help mitigate this issue.
• Ensure a Level Surface: Fire pits should be installed on a stable surface to prevent tipping hazards. A heat-resistant surface like concrete, pavers, or stone is ideal for permanent installations.
• Provide Proper Ventilation: If placing a fire pit in a semi-enclosed space like a patio with a pergola, ensure proper airflow to prevent smoke buildup and maintain safety, especially for gas fire pits.
• Optimize Seating Arrangements: Leave at least 3 feet of clearance around the fire pit for comfortable movement. Arrange seating to encourage conversation while maintaining a safe distance from open flames.

4. Fuel Options: Propane vs. Natural Gas vs. Wood

Choosing the right fuel for your fire pit balances convenience, cost, and ambiance. Each option has benefits and considerations, so selecting the best depends on your lifestyle, budget, and how you plan to use your fire pit.

Propane Fire Pits

• Portable & Easy Setup: Propane fire pits can be moved to different locations and don’t require a fixed gas line. This makes them ideal for renters or those who like to rearrange their outdoor space.
• Quick Ignition & Control: With push-button or electronic ignition, propane fire pits start instantly and allow for adjustable flame control.
• No Smoke, Less Maintenance: Propane burns cleanly, eliminating smoke and reducing cleanup.
• Requires Propane Refills: You’ll need to monitor your propane tank levels and replace or refill tanks regularly, which can be less convenient than a continuous gas supply.

Natural Gas Fire Pits

• Continuous Fuel Supply: Natural gas fire pits connect directly to a home's gas line, eliminating the need for refills.
• Cost-Effective Over Time: While installation requires an upfront investment, natural gas tends to be cheaper per use than propane.
• Professional Installation Required: Since a permanent gas line must be installed, setup involves hiring a licensed professional.
• Stationary Placement: Unlike propane fire pits, natural gas models are fixed in place and cannot be easily moved.

Wood-Burning Fire Pits

• Authentic Fire Experience: The crackling sound, natural warmth, and smoky aroma create a nostalgic ambiance that gas fire pits can’t replicate.
• Fuel Readily Available: Firewood is widely accessible and can often be sourced for free or at a lower cost compared to propane or natural gas.
• More Maintenance Required: Ash and debris must be cleaned out regularly, and starting a fire takes more time and effort than gas options.
• May Have Local Restrictions: Some cities and neighborhoods have regulations against wood-burning fire pits due to fire hazards and air quality concerns. Always check local codes before installing one.

5. Popular Features and Accessories to Enhance Your Fire Pit

A fire pit is more than just a heat source—it’s the centerpiece of outdoor gatherings, providing ambiance, warmth, and even a cooking station. Adding the right features can elevate your fire pit's functionality and aesthetics, making it more enjoyable and long-lasting.

Ignition Systems: Convenience at Your Fingertips

Choosing the right ignition system impacts how easily and safely you can start your fire pit.

• Push-Button Ignition: A simple and affordable option that requires a spark igniter and a gas valve. With just a button press, your fire pit lights up instantly.
• Match-Lit Ignition: A manual option that requires using a lighter or match to ignite the gas. While cost-effective, it requires careful handling.
• Electronic Ignition: The most advanced and convenient choice, electronic ignition systems allow you to start your fire pit with a remote control or a wall switch. Some models even have automatic relight functions for added safety.

Decorative Fill: Style Meets Function

Enhancing the look of your fire pit with decorative fill creates a stunning focal point while improving heat distribution.

• Fire Glass: Available in various colors and shapes, fire glass reflects light beautifully and adds a modern, elegant touch. It’s also heat-resistant and long-lasting.
• Lava Rock: A natural and affordable option that retains heat well and gives a rustic aesthetic. It pairs well with both traditional and contemporary fire pits.
• Ceramic Logs: Designed to mimic real wood without the mess, ceramic logs create a classic, cozy campfire feel without producing ash or embers.

Wind Guards: Keep the Flames Steady

A tempered glass wind guard surrounds the flame, preventing wind from interfering with the fire and ensuring an even burn. Wind guards also help protect guests from direct heat exposure and keep flames contained, making them a great safety feature, especially in breezy areas.

Covers: Protect Your Investment

Investing in a high-quality fire pit cover extends the lifespan of your fire pit by protecting it from the elements.

• Vinyl & Weatherproof Covers: Ideal for shielding against rain, snow, and UV damage, preventing rust and wear.
• Metal & Hard Covers: Dual-purpose lids that protect the burner and can convert the fire pit into a functional tabletop when not in use.

Cooking Grates: Turn Your Fire Pit into a Grill

For those who love outdoor cooking, a cooking grate attachment transforms your fire pit into a BBQ station.

• Swing-Away Grates: Adjustable and removable grates that allow you to control heat exposure while grilling.
• Built-In Grates: Ideal for wood-burning fire pits, these sturdy grates hold cast iron cookware or food directly over the flames.
• Rotisserie Kits: Some fire pits can be upgraded with a rotisserie attachment, perfect for slow-roasting meats over an open flame.

6. How Much Money Can You Expect To Spend On Various Fire Pits 

The cost of a fire pit varies widely depending on factors such as size, material, design, and fuel type. Whether you’re looking for a budget-friendly option or a high-end feature for your outdoor space, understanding the price ranges can help you plan accordingly.

DIY vs. Pre-Built Fire Pits

Building your own fire pit can be a great option if you're looking for a cost-effective alternative. However, it’s important to consider both material and labor costs before committing to a DIY project.

• DIY Fire Pit Costs: A simple stone ring costs as low as $50, and a custom-built design with high-quality materials can cost $500+.
• Pre-built fire Pits often include additional costs for professional installation, which can range from $200 to $1,500, depending on complexity.

Whether you’re looking for convenience, style, or functionality, these features can help you customize your fire pit to suit your lifestyle. Incorporating the right accessories allows you to maximize enjoyment and make your fire pit a year-round centerpiece for outdoor entertainment. 

Ready to Transform Your Backyard?

Whether you're looking for a classic wood-burning fire pit or a high-end fire and water feature, Fire Pit Outfitter has the perfect solution for your space and style.

👉 Explore Our Full Collection

👉 Need help choosing? Call us at 1-800-979-3267 or Contact Us for expert guidance.

Create the outdoor space you’ve dreamed of—starting with the perfect fire pit.